|
|
|
|
Site Map. Click [+] to expand.
|
|
Click 'More' for more detail,
'Next Page' (right arrow), or
'Quick Tour' (control right arrow).
If in a drill down:
you can use Shift-Down or Shift-Up,
or Ctrl-Shift up or down to exit.
If looping over a theme:
you can use Shift-Right or Shift-Left, or
Ctrl-Shift-Left or Right to exit.
When the option is available,
using Alt key toggles the option:
Alt-a - audio,
Alt-i - iconic menu,
Alt-m - music,
Alt-v - video.
View notes for page: Ctrl-Up.
Return to main page: Ctrl-Down
What do you think? Click Feedback to email us or have your say at the end of most pages.
|
Acknowledge coding help from:
W3Schools: Best free web coding tutorials.
StackOverflow
Flaticon
ExtendsClass - PHP syntax checker
Tree Menu
Copyright (c) 2006 Mackley F. Pexton
User ID:
LFD= EN/EN/ SRC=Opt4Cur
LNM= EN TX#= '' SW#= ''
DVC= 'Dtop' BRS= 'Mozilla/5.0 AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko; compatible; ClaudeBot/1.0; +claudebot@anthropic.com)' SWF= 'AllWebSoftware'
SIT= 'GlobalBeliefs.org' A= 'www.globalbeliefs.org'
RET= '' or ''
SLF= '/EN/1_4.php/top_about.php' CUR= '1_4'
NXT= '1_5'
MVM= ','
'1,1'
'1,1'
|
|
1.4 Existence of Minds: Souls and Free Will
Version 1.2 August 2016 (Previous Version)
The questions in
the introduction (Section
0.1.1, paragraph 4) may be refined as we write the Chapter:
Are our minds real
things? Are they different from the matter of the universe? Are our minds
separate from our brains? Are they made of the same stuff as matter but still
fundamentally different? How can we explain consciousness? Do we have souls?
Where do souls come from? Where were our souls before we were born? Where do
they go when we die? Do we go to heaven or hell? Does our soul get
reincarnated? Is this life all there is? See 1.4
This chapter covers the mind-body problem, the philosophy
of mind, the question of free will and the possibility of the existence of
minds without bodies or brains.
Chapter 2.7, on Neuroscience, covers in some detail the
scientific explanations of how minds evolved from simple sensory systems, to
nervous systems, lizard and bird brains and mammalian brains. It explains how
the brain stem and evolutionary older parts of the brain provide feedback loops
between bodily sensations and visceral emotions and an awareness of self and
consciousness. Evolutionary recent parts of the brain, such as the neo-cortex add
additional richness to our awareness, language, better planning and more
self-control over our primitive selves. Science can't yet fully explain consciousness,
and nor do we have a theory of intelligence and emotion, but we are getting
there.
This Chapter focusses on the philosophical aspects, that
are conceptual rather than observational; or common observations that don't require
a scientific background. It refers to scientific results to reinforce points
rather be the sole basis of them and to show where some philosophical
speculations must be constrained by our understanding of reality.
We have a draft plan to
discuss minds and brains under the following topic headings:
|
1. East Eurasian Views of Mind:
|
Can we learn from eastern concepts like Ātman
and Anātman?
|
|
2. West Eurasian Views of Mind:
|
Where does the idea of souls come from?
|
Is it reasonable to break down this area
into these topics at this level?
Click on feedback, or add a comment below, to
tell us if you agree or disagree, or suggest improvements.
|
|
3. Physical Impact on Mind:
|
Why does being drunk make us stupid?
|
|
4. Mind’s Impact on Physicality:
|
How can mental events affect behaviour?
|
|
5. Common Sense View of Mind:
|
Can everyday events tell us anything?
|
|
6. Simplest Explanation of Mind:
|
Fewer complications in brain science?
|
|
7. Brain and Mind:
|
Are mental events simply brain events?
|
|
8. Death and Mental Annihilation
|
When we die, do we really rot?
|
|
9. Liberation from the Afterlife
|
We don't have to fear death itself.
|
|
10. Causality or Chaos:
|
Do we have free will?
|
|
11. The Fact of Choice:
|
Regardless of our understanding of the process, we still
choose.
|
|
12. The Illusion of Self:
|
Our self is a process, an event, rather than an
underlying thing.
|
|
13. Quantum Uncertainty:
|
Can we find rational choice in quantum theory?
|
|
14. Brain Science
|
We can learn a lot from psychology and neuroscience.
|
|
15. Hope for Learning
|
Can the relevant sciences help to improve the world?
|
This is the
current summary of our conclusions in this area:
Mental events are physical events, our minds and our
consciousness are our brains working, physical processes subject to the natural laws of the universe, causal or chaotic:
there are other minds like us, but no spirits, no soul, no reincarnation, no ‘transcendental’ free will, yet we struggle on and value this
life.
more Statement
4
Members can tell us (publicly) what they think of this page. How can we improve it? Enter your comments.
Anyone can tell us (privately) what they think directly by email: click on 'Feedback' below.
Be the first to add a comment on this page.
* * * * * * *
|
Do you know of any great music that would go well with this
page?
Or any of the other pages?
IF
YOU DO, CLICK FEEDBACK.
It could be in any language, or have no words, or just be
instrumental. From pop, to classical, a cappella to orchestral!
Examples of the
music we seek:
● On
the Tenets page, accessed from the main menu, our current choice is a Song
Without Words from Mendelssohn (who died in 1847), Opus 14 Nbr 4, called Contentment. Check it out: the Tenets
conclude most
times, I have a measure of content.
● Chapter 2.3 covers the solar system
and Earth’s development. In there somewhere, surely we should be
hearing Gustav
Holst's The Planets, which premiered 100 years ago. There is a movement for
each of the planets.
Please tell as
much identifying information as you can: a link, and/or the name of the piece
and a person’s name may be enough, but if you know it please also send
the artist/performer, composer/lyricist, year written, year recorded, record
label, copyright owner, or similar details.
We have to worry
about copyright: acknowledge it, and not infringe on it. Music that is
out of copyright, or was never copyrighted (eg like real, ie very old, folk
music) is good. Some material is ‘open source’ allowing others
to use it for free. For newer restricted copyright music we may have to
seek permission to play it, but we can’t afford to pay for it. It
depends on the circumstances. In general, copyright in text, images and music lasts
for 70 years after the year of the creator's death, even if the creator does
not own copyright.
|
|